Gold or Silver? How to Choose the Right Metal for Your Pearl Jewellery

Pearls go with everything — but the metal they're set in changes the whole look, the price, and how long the piece lasts. Here's how to choose.

Silver (S925 sterling): the smart everyday choice

Sterling silver is the most popular setting for freshwater pearl jewellery in Canada, and for good reason:

• Affordable. A sterling silver pearl necklace typically costs a fraction of the same design in gold.
• Versatile. Silver's cool tone flatters most skin tones and works for both casual and formal wear.
• Durable enough. S925 sterling silver is strong for daily wear; it can tarnish over time, but a quick polish restores the shine.

If this is your first pearl piece, silver is the sensible starting point.

Gold: the heirloom choice

• 14K and 18K gold won't tarnish and hold their value far better than silver.
• Warm tone. Yellow gold pairs beautifully with white and cream pearls for a classic, luxurious look.
• Price. Expect to pay several times more than silver — you're buying precious metal content, not just a setting.

Choose gold for engagement pieces, milestone gifts, or jewellery you plan to hand down.

What about gold-plated or vermeil?

Gold-plated silver gives you the gold look at a silver price — a good middle ground for fashion pieces. Just know the plating wears over time with daily use. For pieces you'll wear every day for years, solid gold or sterling silver are better investments.

Matching metal to your pearls

• White pearls: stunning in both; gold warms them up, silver keeps them crisp and modern
• Pink and peach pearls: glow in yellow gold
• Black and grey pearls: dramatic contrast in silver or white gold

The Canadian angle

Whatever metal you choose, buy from a jeweller who tells you exactly what it is. "S925" means genuine sterling silver. "14K" or "18K" with a hallmark means solid gold — not plated. We stamp and disclose every metal we use.

Shop the collection: browse our pearl earrings and pearl necklaces — every order is 15% off with free shipping in Canada and the USA.